Fred M. Eckel, RPh, MS
Mr. Eckel is professor and director of
the Office of Practice Development
and Education at the School of
Pharmacy, University of North Carolina
at Chapel Hill.
The rising cost of monthly health
insurance premiums has meant
that many people cannot afford
insurance. Now, even those with health
insurance
may not be able to afford
some care.
The latest reason is a trend that is
spreading rapidly among insurance companies.
Many insurance plans are placing
specialty drugs into new formulary tiers
that shift a greater proportion of the
drug's cost to patients. Patients who
were previously charged fixed copayments
now pay a share of the drug's cost,
amounting to hundreds or even thousands
of dollars per month. Formularies
with these fourth and even fifth tiers are
already typical among Part D plans, and
recent reports indicate
that they are rapidly
being adopted
by other plans too.
Some insurers say that this tiering
makes patients more aware of the true
cost of drugs and can encourage them
to seek less expensive alternatives. In
practice, this can be problematic. In
many cases, no generic alternatives
exist. Patients
with chronic or acute
conditions may have no choice but to
pay up—if they can afford it.
Critics argue that this approach simply
means shifting costs to patients and that
these plans ultimately could be counterproductive,
because they will cause
patients
to avoid or delay treatment,
resulting
in greater health care costs
later on.
Whatever the intentions behind this
change, it is clearly creating a problem.
The underlying cause is the source of
less agreement, however. Is it that drug
manufacturers are pricing their products
at what the market will bear? Or is it
that intermediaries see opportunities to
increase
profits? For example, pharmacy
benefit managers (PBMs), while claiming
to save employers money, generate an
increasing proportion of their revenue
through specialty drug divisions. They
have the potential to increase profits
both by focusing on these expensive
products and by imposing higher charges
on those who have to pay for them.
The question is whether the PBMs' lucrative
business is to the benefit of the
employers, who are experiencing rapid
increases in specialty drug costs.
Whether this problem is due to specific
players or is merely one indication of
much bigger problems with the overall
health care system, it is clear that change
is needed.
That is one reason that this November's
elections are so important. Your
participation is critical: this is the time to
study the issues and vote for what you
want to see in our future health care
system. Enormous pressure for change
abounds. This is your chance to help
determine the direction those changes
will take.