Guido R. Zanni, PhD
Pharmacists must recognize the warning signs of burnout before the stresses of the job consume and debilitate.
Dr. Zanni is a psychologist and healthsystems
specialist based in
Alexandria, Virginia.
What comes to mind when one
thinks of occupational hazards?
Most think of jobs
involving heavy physical demands or
exposure to potentially life-threatening
situations. Pharmacists, however, are at
high risk for a more subtle, insidious occupational
hazard: burnout. It is psychologically
and physically debilitating—even
career-ending—and its warning signs
should be red flags for all pharmacists.
Defining Burnout
Burnout, a multidimensional syndrome,
is generally recognized only after
symptoms wreak havoc. Acute burnout
does not exist; slowly developing symptoms
worsen progressively. Burnout's 3
core domains to recognize are as follows:
- Cynicism—negative job and workplace
attitude, often directed at staff
and clients, which leads to depersonalization
(eg, a cold, distant attitude);
considered by many as burnout's
distinguishing characteristic
- Emotional exhaustion—feeling physically
and emotionally depleted, apathetic,
and indifferent
- Ineffectiveness—with time, a sense of
inadequacy, which leads to devaluing
one's own work and causes anxiety
and trepidation from a belief that new
work tasks are meaningless1,2
Burnout and stress differ. Stress may
cause emotional exhaustion, but burnout
always generates cynicism and a sense
of inadequacy (characteristics that are
absent from normal job-related stress).
Job stress, however, generally includes
somatic symptoms (eg, anxiety) that are
not necessarily present with burnout.
One also is usually aware of stress reactions
but does not always notice burnout
(symptoms can take months to surface).
When workplace expectations and
realities are disparate, burnout is a given.
The following 6 areas are often troublesome
for pharmacies:
- Work overload—when workload
chronically exceeds realistic levels,
staff is taxed with additional job responsibilities,
and work–family
boundaries become blurred, often
exacerbated by on-call demands and
e-mail communications
- Lack of control—inflexibility cramps
novel approaches, job sharing, and
innovation as staff struggles to stay
within the limits of rigid procedures
- Breakdown in community—without
a sense of belonging and job security,
staff cohesiveness declines
- Unfairness—evaluations fail to recognize
outstanding performance, or
meager rewards are given randomly
and without apparent reason
- Insufficient rewards—management
rewards staff only rarely or emphasizes
negative outcomes (ignoring
successful efforts)
- Value conflict—the organization's
actions differ from its public façade
(eg, management emphasizes screening
for drug interactions and safety in
advertisements but provides antiquated
technology), or increasingly
an employee's values might be
ignored (eg, an organization provides
the morning-after pill but offers no
conscience clause for employees to
opt out of filling these prescriptions)2
Pharmacy is fertile ground for burnout
due to chronic staffing shortages, the
heavily regulated environment, excessive
documentation, the inability to control requests, a focus on negative outcomes (eg, prescription
errors), incongruence between expertise and job components (eg,
certified in disease management but performing peel-and-stick
bench work), lack of positive feedback (eg, drug-use reviews rarely
commented on), and few rewards for improved patient care or preventing
contraindications. Inadequate pharmacy resources seem
to reach epidemic proportions. In a recent pharmacy poll, 61.5% of
respondents indicated their employer has unrealistic expectations
regarding work that can be accomplished in an 8-hour day.3
Burnout's Warning Signs
Although >30 signs of burnout exist, the box highlights 10 classic
signs that relate to pharmacists. Not all will experience each
symptom; most experience at least 1 in each of burnout's 3
domains. Identifying with ≥1 of the signs listed in the box occasionally
or regarding specific incidents is normal. When it becomes constant,
action is needed, or burnout will consume and debilitate.
Interventions
Pharmacists with burnout must self-assess, looking for workplace
conditions that fuel burnout. The following are some effective
strategies for each workplace antecedent:
Workplace Overload. Avoid focusing on quantity or working
harder; instead, examine the process used to complete tasks with
an eye to change. Explore job sharing or trading assignments with
colleagues. Overhaul daily routine and reshuffle tasks.
Lack of Control. Define and separate work and home life. Avoid
working while eating. Take breaks but avoid discussing and reading
work-related material. Learn to say "no" when asked to voluntarily
take on more assignments.
Insufficient Rewards. Seek positive feedback. Inform supervisors
that both positive and negative feedback are important to you.
Lack of Community. Seek others suffering from burnout and
form a peer support group. Initiate actions that foster interpersonal
relationships; talk to a career-seasoned mentor.
Unfairness. Work with supervisors to improve the workplace.
Document personal accomplishments to help ensure fairness.
Value Conflict. Seek out value-compatible assignments. Focus
on the intrinsic value of your work, not on organizational constraints.
Explore potential transfers. If the value conflict is irreconcilable,
seek counseling or make a career change.1
Young Professionals Take Note
Studies demonstrate that burnout affects younger professionals
disproportionately, especially in the first 5 years of their career.
Young or struggling pharmacists may hesitate to discuss concerns
with supervisors, confusing feeling overwhelmed with personal
inadequacy.1,2 Because most managers rarely discuss burnout, the
staff struggles. Some find successful interventions or a mentor to
help; others quit the job or the profession. Adopting prevention
strategies to ward off or minimize burnout is a key component of
ensuring job satisfaction.
Table |
 |
Adapted from references 1, 2, and 4. |
References
- Maslach C. Burnout, The Cost of Caring. Cambridge, MA: Malor Books; 2003.
- Maslach C, Leiter M. The Truth About Burnout. San Francisco, CA: John Wiley & Sons; 1997.
- Smith M, Jaffe-Gill E, Segal R. Burnout: signs, symptoms, and prevention. www.helpguide.org/mental/burnout_signs_symptoms.htm. Accessed October 26, 2007.
- PharmacyOneSource. Poll Results: Do you feel your employer has unrealistic expectations of what you can accomplish in an 8-hour day? www.pharmacyonesource.com/members/surveys/se/poll/results.asp?survey_id=557. Accessed October 8, 2007.